New York Times

Why useless surgery is still popular

Before a drug can be marketed, it has to go through rigorous testing to show it is safe and effective. Surgery, though, is different. The Food and Drug Administration does not regulate surgical procedures. So what happens when an operation is subjected to and fails the ultimate test — a clinical trial in which patients are randomly assigned to have it or not?

The expectation is that medical practice will change if an operation turns out not to help.

If only.

It looks as if the onus is on patients to ask what evidence, if any, shows that surgery is better than other options.

Take what happened with spinal fusion, an operation that welds together adjacent vertebrae to relieve back pain from worn-out discs. Unlike most operations, it actually was tested in four clinical trials. The conclusion: Surgery was no better than alternative nonsurgical treatments, like supervised exercise and therapy to help patients deal with their fear of back pain. In both groups, the pain usually diminished or went away.

 The studies were completed by the early 2000s and should have been enough to greatly limit or stop the surgery, says Dr. Richard Deyo, professor of evidence-based medicine at the Oregon Health and Sciences University. But that did not happen, according to a recent report. Instead, spinal fusion rates increased — the clinical trials had little effect.

THE LATEST NEWS: January 2018

WELCOME TO THE BOARD Joann Serafini Ross is a native of Albany, New York and holds a BA in Communications from SUNY, New Paltz, New York. Her varied and diverse career has been filled with hard work and great experiences, all culminating in her current leadership and...

The Development of a New Technique

Innovations and breakthroughs can be the result of years’ worth of effort, multiple failures, and even happy accidents. For Dr. Marko Bodor, it was the driving need to ensure his patients were being diagnosed and treated in the most accurate, timely, effective and...

2017 Accomplishments

The Napa Medical Research Foundation continues to make major contributions in the field of regenerative medicine thanks to our innovative research team, dedicated staff and generous donors. Director of Research, Dr. Marko Bodor, combines his expertise in ultrasound and...

NMRF comments on Wall Street Journal article about stem cell research in U.S.

The recent Wall Street Journal article, “Stem Cells for Knee Injuries? U.S. Doctors Investigate”, presents an important case for the critical research being performed across the country to prove the efficacy of regenerative biologic treatments, including stem cells...

Investing in the Future

 Reduce Pain. Increase Mobility + Function. Improve Quality of Life. All the research conducted through the Napa Medical Research Foundation, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization, is fully funded through generous donations received from individuals and family...

Napa Valley Marketplace magazine

Dr. Marko Bodor through the Bodor Clinic and the Napa Medical Research Foundation is pioneering new techniques in regenerative medicine to keep patients free of pain and off the operating table. Using the patient’s own red blood cell platelets and stem cells, Dr....

Welcome to the Board, Joann Serafini Ross

Joann Serafini Ross is a native of Albany, New York and holds a BA in Communications from SUNY, New Paltz, New York. Her varied and diverse career has been filled with hard work and great experiences, all culminating in her current leadership and mentoring roles....

Surgery During Harvest

Michael Wolf, owner of Michael Wolf Vineyard Services and long-time Napa Valley grape producer, suffered for years from Carpal Tunnel Syndrome in both wrists.   Like the 12 million other Americans with this condition, Mike was experiencing numbness, tingling, and...

Welcome Dr. Harry Genant

Harry K. Genant, MD, is Professor Emeritus of the University of California San Francisco and currently serves as a Senior Consultant, and past Member of the Board of Directors and Chairman Emeritus of Bioclinica-Synarc, Inc., a global contract research organization he...

Response to British Journal of Sport & Exercise Medicine

The British Medical Journal Open Sports & Exercise Medicine recently published an article titled, “Normal platelet function in platelet concentrates requires non-platelet cells: a comparative in vitro evaluation of leukocyte-rich (type 1a) and leukocyte-poor (type...

Categories

 Reduce Pain. Increase Mobility + Function. Improve Quality of Life.

All the research conducted through the Napa Medical Research Foundation, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization, is fully funded through generous donations received from individuals and family foundations.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This